1 Carmine Street bet. Bleecker & Bedford Streets
I wasn't sure if I'd like Victory Garden's goat's milk fro-yo at first. My first brush with goat's milk wasn't exactly pleasant. When I was a kid, my mom had once mistakenly bought goat's milk instead of regular milk and I remember it ruining my bowl of cereal with its strong taste. But I'm glad I gave it another chance. I love the smooth flavor of salted caramel in any dessert, really, but this soft-serve version still lets the tangy, aromatic character of the goat's milk shine through. The dense halvah crumbles add texture and a lovely nuttiness. It's a bit more expensive than your typical frozen yogurt treat, but well worth it.